Grow Your Podcast Like a Pro (8 Powerful Insights)

🚀 Grow Your Podcast Like a Pro (8 Powerful Insights)

Want to turn your podcast into a growth machine? We’ve distilled 8 killer insights from Matt McGarry (founder of GrowLetter.co), who’s a wizard at scaling newsletters. Spoiler: these tips aren’t just for newsletters—they’re perfect for podcasts too.

Let’s dive into how you can supercharge your podcast’s growth and revenue.

1. Build an Owned Audience

Building an owned audience is essential for control and growth. Matt nails it: email, SMS, and podcasts allow direct audience access, avoiding algorithmic interference. For podcasters, this means doubling down on these channels to create a self-sustaining feedback loop. Free content lowers barriers to entry and expands reach, while monetizing through ads ensures sustainability.

Action Steps for Podcast Growth

1. Own Your Channels:
   Start a newsletter tied to your podcast. Use it to share episode highlights, bonus insights, and listener-exclusive updates.

2. Leverage Call-to-Actions (CTAs):
   In every podcast episode, promote your newsletter. Example: "Love this episode? Subscribe to my newsletter for more insider tips!"

3. No Paywalls for Core Content:
   Keep episodes and newsletters accessible. Experiment with ads for revenue, but reserve premium offerings (e.g., bonus content) for paywalls if needed.

4. Focus Outreach Efforts:
   Direct social media and guest appearances to funnel followers into your podcast or newsletter. "Follow for great content, subscribe for the full experience!" Use Podchaser Pro’s audience demographics to find shows similar to your own. Use Pro’s “Tell Me Why” feature to vet the podcast and have it write a tailored, relevant guest pitch for you.

5. Build Synergy Across Channels:
   Use your podcast to tease newsletter exclusives. Example: "Check out the show notes or my newsletter for a deeper dive on today’s topic."

2. Collect First-Party Data

First-party data is a goldmine for understanding and growing your audience. For podcasters, knowing your listeners' preferences and demographics can transform how you market your show, engage your audience, and sell ad space. Personalized experiences build loyalty and improve monetization opportunities.

Action Steps for Podcast Growth

1. Start with the Basics:
   Use a newsletter sign-up form to collect emails, asking for minimal information upfront (e.g., name, email, and favorite podcast genres).

2. Build Gradually:
   After sign-up, use surveys or polls to gather more data. Example: "Which topics interest you most: A, B, or C?" This keeps engagement high without overwhelming new subscribers.

3. Use Data for Personalization:
   Segment your email list based on listener preferences (e.g., comedy fans get recommendations for similar shows). Tailored outreach feels more personal and keeps people engaged.

4. Offer Value for Data:
   Incentivize data collection. Example: "Answer three quick questions about yourself to unlock a free bonus episode!"

5. Leverage Data for Monetization:
   Share anonymized listener profiles (e.g., "Our audience is 75% professionals in the tech industry") with potential sponsors to justify ad rates and attract niche advertisers. Substantiate your audience demos with Podchaser Pro’s demographic data.

6. Automate Engagement:
   Set up automations based on listener actions. Example: If someone hasn’t opened an email in 30 days, send a re-engagement campaign with an enticing subject line like, "We miss you! Here’s a special gift."

3. Be Hyper-Scale or Hyper-Niche

Choose your lane: scale or niche. For podcasters, this translates into either going big (broad appeal, mass advertising opportunities) or going deep (highly specific topics for premium audiences). Straddling the middle can dilute your value to advertisers and listeners.

Action Steps for Podcast Growth

1. Define Your Strategy:

   • Hyper-scale: Focus on universally appealing topics (e.g., personal finance, pop culture) and invest in mass marketing to grow your listener base.

   • Hyper-niche: Target a specific community or industry (e.g., drone technology or vegan parenting). Create content only they care about.

2. Conduct Audience Research:
   Use surveys or analytics tools to assess your current audience. Are they generalists or specialists? Align your content accordingly.

3. Tailor Your Messaging:

   • For hyper-scale, highlight your reach when pitching advertisers: “We deliver 1M+ impressions monthly.”

   • For hyper-niche, emphasize audience quality: “Our listeners are 90% senior executives in the fintech space.”

4. Optimize Content for Your Choice:

   • Hyper-scale: Focus on accessibility and trending topics. Keep episodes relatable to everyone.

   • Hyper-niche: Dive deep into specific pain points, industry news, or advanced topics your niche craves.

5. Adapt Advertising Strategies:

   • Hyper-scale: Sell volume-based ads to brands looking for mass awareness.

   • Hyper-niche: Pitch higher CPMs to advertisers seeking valuable, targeted audiences.

6. Double Down on Your Choice:
   Consistency is key. Avoid the temptation to pivot or mix your strategy—it can confuse your audience and advertisers.

4. Two Ways to Scale Niche: Go Horizontal or Run Negative CAC

Scaling niche media means either going wide (multiple niches) or deep (maximizing one niche). The "house of brands" strategy, like Industry Dive’s, is a proven horizontal model. Negative CAC is a clever vertical approach: using ad revenue to acquire an audience, then monetizing further with products or services. Both methods offer powerful growth paths for podcasters.

Action Steps for Podcast Growth

1. Explore Horizontal Growth:

   • Build a Podcast Network: Launch new shows targeting complementary niches. Example: If you host a cybersecurity podcast, start another on fintech or IT innovation.

   • Cross-Promote Relentlessly: Use your existing audience to drive traffic to new podcasts. Example: “Loved this? Check out our new show diving deeper into [topic]!”

2. Experiment with Negative CAC:

   • Use podcast ad revenue to fund growth. Example: “Sponsored by [Brand]. Listen while we grow!”

   • Invest ad profits into audience-building strategies like paid ads, collaborations, or content marketing.

3. Monetize Beyond Media:

   • Sell products: Create e-books, online courses, or consulting services related to your niche.

   • Offer services: Launch a subscription for exclusive research or a premium community for your listeners.

4. Identify Synergies Across Shows:
   Build cross-brand value. Example: A network with podcasts on banking, HR, and healthcare can package ad deals for companies serving all three industries.

5. Leverage Data for New Opportunities:

   • Analyze audience preferences to decide your next niche. Example: If your listeners love HR content, a podcast on workplace mental health could resonate.

   • Use listener demographics to pitch better ad deals or align product development.

6. Plan for Long-Term Scalability:
   Whether horizontal or vertical, ensure each addition (brand, product, or service) strengthens your overall strategy. Avoid overstretching.

5. Negative CAC is Media’s Moat

Negative CAC is a game-changer for media-driven businesses. By monetizing media upfront (eg offering sponsorships), you create a self-sustaining funnel for your core business. Podcasters can use this strategy to turn their show into a launchpad for broader ventures, whether it’s SaaS, marketplaces, or content-to-commerce ecosystems.

Action Steps for Podcast Growth

1. Identify Complementary Business Opportunities:

   • Think about your niche. What products or services align naturally?

   • Example: A fitness podcast could launch a workout app or meal-planning service.

2. Start with Media Monetization:

   • Focus on high-quality sponsorships and ads to fund initial growth.

   • Use audience analytics to pitch the right advertisers for your niche.

3. Develop a Funnel for Your Core Business:

   • Tease your product or service within your podcast. Example: "Stay tuned for an exciting new tool to help [solve niche problem]!"

   • Offer free trials or discounts exclusively to your podcast audience.

4. Learn from the Best:

   • Study MeatEater, Doug DeMuro, and Epic Gardening for ideas on how to integrate commerce with content.

   • Example: Doug DeMuro used Cars and Bids to connect directly with his car-loving audience. Could your podcast offer a similar marketplace or service?

5. Leverage Partnerships to Scale:

   • Partner with brands that fit your niche. Example: A tech podcast could collaborate with a SaaS tool to cross-promote and share audiences.

   • Use their ad spend to grow your audience, reducing your own costs.

6. Reinvest in Growth:

   • Funnel ad revenue into expanding your audience or building new verticals.

   • Example: Invest in video podcasting or social media to diversify and scale.

7. Focus on the Long Game:
   Negative CAC is a snowball effect. Build trust and value with your audience first, then scale your business opportunities over time.

6. Don’t Just Be a Podcast

A podcast should be the foundation, not the entirety, of your brand. By expanding into other channels—like social media, newsletters, and SEO-driven blogs—you can diversify your audience, increase discoverability, and protect against platform risk. Each channel supports the others, creating a growth flywheel.

Action Steps for Podcast Growth

1. Expand Beyond Audio:

   • Start a blog to repurpose podcast episodes into SEO-friendly articles.

   • Example: “Top 5 Insights from [Episode X]” as a blog post that drives search traffic.

2. Build Your Social Presence:

   • Use social media to promote podcast clips, engage with followers, and drive traffic to your show and newsletter.

   • Focus on platforms where your audience hangs out. Example: LinkedIn for professionals, TikTok for younger audiences.

3. Launch Owned Channels:

   • Start a newsletter. Include episode updates, bonus content, and behind-the-scenes stories to keep listeners engaged.

   • Build an SMS list for exclusive offers or instant updates. Example: “Get a text when a new episode drops!”

4. Create a Private Community:

   • Launch a Discord, Slack group, or Patreon community where listeners can interact and deepen their connection with your brand.

   • Promote it as a place for exclusive discussions or bonus Q&A sessions.

5. Optimize with SEO:

   • Ensure your website includes show notes, episode transcripts, and blog content optimized for search engines.

   • Use keywords related to your niche. Example: A parenting podcast could rank for “best advice for new parents.”

6. Cross-Promote Your Channels:

   • Use each channel to promote the others. Example: Share newsletter links on social, direct blog readers to your podcast, and use podcast CTAs to grow your newsletter.

7. Track and Adapt:

   • Measure engagement on each channel and double down on what works. Let data guide your diversification strategy.

7. Consumer Subscriptions can be a Trap

Paid content subscriptions can limit growth and audience accessibility, especially for podcasts. Instead of paywalls, focus on making your content free to reach a wider audience and monetize through ads. Use that audience to sell premium, high-value products and services. This strategy combines reach and revenue without alienating potential listeners.

Action Steps for Podcast Growth

1. Ditch Paywalls:

   • Keep your podcast free to maximize reach. Focus on building a large, engaged audience.

   • Monetize with dynamic ad insertion or sponsorship deals tailored to your niche.

2. Upsell High-Value Products:

   • Identify premium offerings aligned with your podcast’s theme. Example: A business podcast could offer online courses or coaching programs.

   • Create compelling CTAs to drive sales. Example: “Want to dive deeper? Check out our exclusive course at [website].”

3. Host Live Events:

   • Organize webinars, workshops, or in-person meetups. Charge for access to these events to create an additional revenue stream.

   • Example: A podcast about creativity could host a “Creative Bootcamp” workshop.

4. Build a Community:

   • Launch a paid mastermind group or private forum for your most engaged listeners. Example: A fitness podcast could offer a monthly subscription to a private fitness challenge community.

5. Leverage E-commerce:

   • Develop physical products related to your niche. Example: A travel podcast could sell branded travel journals or gear.

   • Promote these during episodes with seamless integrations.

6. Utilize Your Free Content as a Funnel:

   • Use your podcast and newsletter to showcase your expertise and build trust.

   • Tease premium offerings within free content. Example: “We cover the basics here, but our full guide [available in the course] goes even deeper.”

7. Monetize with a Blended Approach:

   • Combine ad revenue with product sales to diversify income streams.

   • Reinvest ad profits into growing your audience, creating a sustainable cycle.

8. You Need Multiple Revenue Streams

Relying solely on ads is risky, especially with fluctuating CPMs. Podcasters need multiple revenue streams to insulate their income and scale sustainably. Diversification ensures stability and opens up new opportunities to monetize niche audiences creatively.

Action Steps for Podcast Growth

1. Expand Revenue Channels:

   • Explore sponsorships, affiliate marketing, and e-commerce as foundational streams.

   • Example: Partner with brands for sponsorships while promoting affiliate links in your show notes.

2. Create Events:

   • Host virtual or in-person events tailored to your audience. Example: A history podcast could organize a virtual "deep dive" series on niche topics.

   • Charge for event access and upsell additional products like recordings or related guides.

3. Leverage Licensing Deals:

   • License your content to third parties, such as platforms, networks, or educational institutions.

   • Example: Package themed podcast episodes for corporate training or school curricula.

4. Offer Digital Info Products:

   • Sell downloadable guides, templates, or courses. Example: A productivity podcast could sell a “30-Day Productivity Planner.”

   • Bundle these with exclusive podcast content to add value.

5. Launch Memberships or Communities:

   • Create paid tiers offering ad-free episodes, bonus content, or exclusive Q&A sessions.

   • Use platforms like Patreon or Ko-fi to manage memberships efficiently.

6. Dive into E-commerce:

   • Sell merchandise or niche-related products. Example: A cooking podcast could sell branded kitchen tools or cookbooks.

7. Use Affiliate Marketing:

   • Partner with brands to promote products, earning commissions on sales.

   • Mention them organically in episodes. Example: “We use [Brand], and here’s why it’s great for [niche problem].”

8. Offer Lead Generation Services:

   • Collaborate with B2B brands to generate leads through your audience. Example: A tech podcast could run campaigns for SaaS tools.

9. Monitor Industry Trends:

   • Stay ahead of declining CPMs by pivoting early to new revenue models.

   • Example: Explore AI tools or video podcasting to broaden reach and revenue potential.

The Wrap-Up

Matt McGarry’s insights are crystal clear: your podcast is just the start. Build an ecosystem around it. Own your audience. Diversify your revenue. Stay flexible and forward-thinking.

Action beats ideas every time—so take one of these tips and apply it this week. Big wins don’t come from luck; they come from consistent moves in the right direction.

If you have questions or ideas, reply to this email—I’d love to hear from you!

P.S. Share this with a podcasting friend who’s ready to level up. Let’s grow together. 🚀

The Top New Podcasts of 2024

You can access the best new podcasts that published their first episode in 2024 right here. They're sorted by Podchaser's PowerScore so you can understand their total popularity, instead of just their listenership. We also published the list in video format here.

Want to see this data (and more) up close? Consider a Podchaser Pro subscription.

• 5.5M podcasts

• Deep demographic data

• Monthly and per episode reach

• “Tell Me Why” podcast vetting

• and so much more

Follow Podchaser on LinkedIn and Twitter